Poll discussing > What did you think of Star Wars III...

1 2 3
<< Prev Next >>

#209474 by fx2050 Donor

(Power User) at 2005-05-23 14:30:28 (8 years ago) - [Report]

not seen yet, awaiting a decent release.

shouldnt be too long

wont waste cash on cinema to be cramped up in a seat with average quality screen.

come on digital cinema's!!!!

#209483 by unknown[9089] at 2005-05-23 14:38:35 (8 years ago) - [Report]

saw is at flicks and at home

Apart from soem very weak acting at times the film was good

I had to watch it 3 times to fully realise this

Storyline was pretty good imo and connected the old movies to the new ones rather nicely I thaught

just a shame about the odd bit of weak acting

#209502 by unknown[38816] at 2005-05-23 14:59:56 (8 years ago) - [Report]

I haven't seen it yet, but it seems amazing!

#209518 by VeryBadGuy Donor

(Mad Ultra Mod) at 2005-05-23 15:23:20 (8 years ago) - [Report]

I think it was great.
But some peoples reactions have made me really think.

IF these three movies had been made first and were followed by A New Hope, The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi..would we look at those three films in the same way?
I hear people talking about weak acting..bad dialogue and too many special effects...but aren't these the same things that made the first three films great when we first saw them?

If you want great directing go watch Spielberg..acting? Go see Pacino or Deniro..if you want great dialogue go check out a copy of shakespear from your local library.

If you want two hours of fun and fantasy go watch star wars and enjoy it for what it is.

#209548 by Carpy (Anti - Royalist) at 2005-05-23 15:57:57 (8 years ago) - [Report]

I thought it was great

maybe if the film was on around 30mins longer, because some of the scenes were rushed along.
Not giving the veiwer time to take them in.

Also can anyone tell me how one minute yoda and sidious are fighting on a senate pod, then it cuts to anakin vs obi, then next time we see them yoda is 4 tiers below sidious?

I really liked the Jedi purge scene.
I also like the yoda vs sidious dual better than anikin vs Obi.

Anyone else think some scenes were quite emotional?
Like the jedi purge and the bit where Obi finds out anakin killed the younglings?
''The boy you once knew is gone, consumed by darth vader''

Last edited by Carpy at 2005-05-23 16:03:52

#209563 by unknown[9089] at 2005-05-23 16:10:43 (8 years ago) - [Report]

Carpy wrote:

I have to agree

Some scenes did seam rushed whiel others went on a little too long

and yes the movie was rather emotional in places , it certainly showed us a side of darth/anakin I dotn think anyoen expected

We knew darth was a twat but bloody hell the man is pure evil that seams to be driven by love , thus I think hsi downfall was his love , but thats not a bad thing ..

#209594 by unknown[75352] at 2005-05-23 16:45:49 (8 years ago) - [Report]

i dunno .. i agree with what many people say... but .. there is always a BUT...
Star Wars is to me .... like Lego is to a 5 year old... BUT when u get older... it dies out..

Star Trek on the other hand is like... Sweet Candy.... in different flavours... =) it never dies out...

#209607 by naresh Donor

(IndianA Vip) at 2005-05-23 17:00:45 (8 years ago) - [Report]

It pwned all other movies.

It was the missing peice in the star wars collection :-D

#209619 by roshankv007 Donor

(Power User) at 2005-05-23 17:04:59 (8 years ago) - [Report]

Matte010 wrote:

As said in Unreal Tournament: "Dominating!!"

i saw it in the theatre and it rocked! slighltly overrated but it still rocks

#209644 by demagh (User) at 2005-05-23 17:18:16 (8 years ago) - [Report]

[1] over rated
[2] who the hell voted "movie of the year"

#209660 by Carpy (Anti - Royalist) at 2005-05-23 17:31:27 (8 years ago) - [Report]

demagh wrote:

[1] over rated
[2] who the hell voted "movie of the year"

1. no
2. me
na j/k not movie of the year but it will be the highest grossing no probs.

#209686 by unknown[82220] at 2005-05-23 17:52:21 (8 years ago) - [Report]

It was over rated. I saw it on the cinema. It was not worth the money

, the old movies ownz.

#209869 by unknown[5093] at 2005-05-23 19:50:25 (8 years ago) - [Report]

Star Wars is for kids like 10 year olds. I don't know what does anyone older see in those movies. I haven't ever liked 'em. I'm not sure if I've even seen one of them from the beginning till the end. So I'll answer:

"What is Star Wars III" here :-P

(it's poo)

#209924 by unknown[68404] at 2005-05-23 20:28:24 (8 years ago) - [Report]

It wasnt a bad movie. Just story was just hasted. Seems like they hasted it coz it was the third movie.
As single movie it was entertaining but as a star wars movie it was crap.

#209964 by unknown[809] at 2005-05-23 20:50:30 (8 years ago) - [Report]

It was good but it was a litte too much CGI effects.. nothing beats the first 3 movies thoose are classics.

#209991 by unknown[60386] at 2005-05-23 21:10:40 (8 years ago) - [Report]

Well after seeing Episode 1 and 2 (which were absolute shit) I was expecting much of the same for this one, but in fact it was the oposite and was really quite good. Personally I would have done this movie only for the prequel and not even made the first 2.

#209992 by hakk Donor

(Power User) at 2005-05-23 21:11:00 (8 years ago) - [Report]

it is absolutley fabiolus!!!!! =P!

no, but seriosley. it's great!

#210065 by unknown[10043] at 2005-05-23 22:02:13 (8 years ago) - [Report]

It was way better then ep 1 and 2 that's for sure.

I really dug the Clone Wars animation eps on cartoon network, those were simply bad ass.

#210084 by unknown[82825] at 2005-05-23 22:12:13 (8 years ago) - [Report]

i didn't vote because there wasn't an option to describe what i thought. I DID go watch it in theatres but i thought it was ok. but doubt it would be considered "best" You should og added a "Watched it, it was ok/average" to the choices.

#210177 by unknown[77277] at 2005-05-23 22:54:05 (8 years ago) - [Report]